The Joe A. Callaway Award
Current Recipients: Steven Epp and Kimber Elayne Sprawl
Past Recipients: 1989-Present
| Year | Recipient | Play | Production | 
| 2025 | Steven Epp | Henry IV | Theatre for a New Audience | 
| Kimber Elayne Sprawl | Othello | Lead Producer: Brian Anthony Moreland prezented at the Shubert Theater | |
| 2024 | Marin Ireland | Uncle Vanya | O'Henry Productions' Loft | 
| Jonathan Hadary | Uncle Vanya | Lincoln Center Theatre | |
| 2023 | Michael Patrick Thornton | A Doll's House | The Hudson Theatre | 
| 2022 | Roslyn Ruff | The Skin of our Teeth | |
| Carson Elrod | The Alchemist | ||
| 2019 | Danielle Brooks | Much Ado About Nothing | The Public Theatre | 
| John Keating | O'Casey Cycle | Irish Repertory Theatre | |
| 2018 | Alison Fraser | Heartbreak House | Gingold Theatre Group | 
| Jay O. Sanders | Uncle Vanya | Hunter College Theatre Project | |
| 2017 | Mary Testa | The Inspector General. | Red Bull Theater | 
| Arnie Burton | The Inspector General. | Red Bull Theater | |
| 2016 | Lisa Harrow | Red Bull Theater | Read More | |
| Corey Stoll | Read More | ||
| 2015 | Thomas Jay Ryan | A Month In The Country | CSC | Read More | 
| Kelley Curran | Tis A Pity She'S A Whore | Red Bull Theatre | Read More | |
| 2014 | Paxton Whitehead | The Heir Apparent | Classic Stage Company | 
| Suzanne Bertish | The Heir Apparent | Classic Stage Company | |
| 2013 | J. Smith- Cameron | Juno And The Paycock | Irish Repertory Theatre | 
| Jonathan Cake | Much Ado About Nothing | Theatre for a New Audience | |
| 2012 | Michael Shannon | Uncle Vanya | Soho Rep | 
| Merritt Wever | Uncle Vanya | Soho Rep | |
| 2011 | Derek Smith | The Witch Of Edmonton | Red Bull Theatre | 
| Danai Gurira | Measure For Measure | The Public Theatre | |
| 2010 | Matthew Rauch | The Duchess Of Malfi | Red Bull Theatre | 
| Lily Rabe | The Merchant Of Venice | The Public Theatre | |
| 2009 | John Douglas Thompson | Othello/ The Emperor Jones | Theatre for a New Audience/ Irish Repertory Theatre | 
| Kate Frobes | Othello | Theatre for a New Audience | |
| 2008 | Everett Quinton | Women Beware Women | Red Bull Theatre | 
| Kathryn Meisle | Women Beware Women | Red Bull Theatre | |
| 2007 | Byron Jennings | Is He Dead? | |
| Lauren Ambrose | Romeo And Juliet | The Public Theatre | |
| 2006 | Michael Stuhlbarg | The Voysey Inheritance | Atlantic Theatre Co. | 
| Lily Rabe | Heartbreak House | Roundabout | |
| 2005 | Elizabeth Marvel | Hedda Gabler | NY Theatre Workshop | 
| Sean McNall | The Gentleman Dancing-Master | Pearl Theatre | |
| 2004 | Robert Hock | The Imaginary Invalid | Pearl Theatre | 
| Joanne Camp | The Imaginary Invalid | Pearl Theatre | |
| 2003 | Carol Schultz | The Rivals | Pearl Theatre | 
| Kathryn Meisle | Tartuffe | Roundabout | |
| Earl Hindman | Julius Caesar | Theater for a New Audience | |
| 2002 | Celeste Ciulla | She Stoops To Conquer | Pearl Theatre | 
| Evan Robertson | Much Ado About Nothing | Pearl Theatre | |
| 2001 | Kate Burton | Hedda Gabler | Ambassador Theatre | 
| Larry Pine | The Seagull | Shakespeare in the Park | |
| 2000 | Myra Carter | King John | Theater for a New Audience | 
| Byron Jennings | Waste | Theater for a New Audience | |
| 1999 | Anne Dudek | Iphigenia | Theater for a New Audience | 
| No male choice | |||
| 1998 | Zoe Wanamaker | Electra | Barrymore Theatre | 
| Liev Schreiber | Cymbeline | New York Shakespeare Festival | |
| 1997 | Helen Carey | London Assurance | Roundabout | 
| Max Wright | Ivanov | Vivian Beaumont | |
| 1996 | Kathleen Chalfant | The Merry Wives Of Windsor, Henry V | New York Shakespeare Festival | 
| Frank Langella | The Father | Roundabout | |
| 1995 | Laila Robins | The Merchant Of Venice | New York Shakespeare Festival | 
| Brian Bedford | The Moliere Comedies | Roundabout | |
| 1994 | Lurn Linney | Hedda Gabler | Roundabout | 
| Robert Stattel | Titus Andronicus | Theatre for a New Audience | |
| 1993 | Maryann Plunkett | Saint Joan | National Actors Theatre | 
| Robert Sean Leonard | Candida | roundabout | |
| 1992 | Maryann Plunkett | The Seagull, Master Builder, A Little Hotel, On The Side | National Actors Theatre | 
| Jake Weber | As You Like It | New York Shakespeare Festival | |
| 1991 | Mary Beth Hurt | Othello | New York Shakespeare Festival | 
| Campbell Scott | Pericles, Prince Of Tyre | New York Shakespeare Festival | |
| 1990 | Mary Alice | Richard III | New York Shakespeare Festival | 
| Philip Bosco | The Miser | Circle in the Square | |
| 1989 | Victor Garber | The Devil'S Disciple | Circle in the Square | 
| Alfre Woodard | The Winter's Tale | New York Shakespeare Festival | 
 
                         
            
              
            
            
          
              